任蓉. 试论陪审团审判制度的优势——从与职业法官审判比较的视角[J]. 南昌航空大学学报(社会科学版), 2012, 14(4): 43-47.
引用本文: 任蓉. 试论陪审团审判制度的优势——从与职业法官审判比较的视角[J]. 南昌航空大学学报(社会科学版), 2012, 14(4): 43-47.
REN Rong. On the Advantages of the Jury Trial System——A Perspective of Comparing with the Professional Judge Trial[J]. JOURNAL OF NANCHANG HANGKONG UNIVERSITY(SOCLAL SCIENCES), 2012, 14(4): 43-47.
Citation: REN Rong. On the Advantages of the Jury Trial System——A Perspective of Comparing with the Professional Judge Trial[J]. JOURNAL OF NANCHANG HANGKONG UNIVERSITY(SOCLAL SCIENCES), 2012, 14(4): 43-47.

试论陪审团审判制度的优势——从与职业法官审判比较的视角

On the Advantages of the Jury Trial System——A Perspective of Comparing with the Professional Judge Trial

  • 摘要: 陪审团审判制度的确存在某些缺陷,但与职业法官审判相比,其所谓弊端正是其优势所在:陪审团审判产生的公信力使得上诉率低,从而极佳地避免了各方面资源的浪费;陪审团的大众经验和集体评议方式能超越职业法官限于专业视角或行业利益所导致的偏见;陪审团在审判过程中引进的社会价值观,可以克服职业法官社会经验的不足、业务活动的惯性思维和心智能力的个体差异;陪审团审判能克服职业法官审判官僚主义、机械呆板及远离民众等缺陷,不失为民众参与司法的有效形式。

     

    Abstract: As is known,the jury trial system has its disadvantages,but compared with the professional judge trial,its so-called disadvantages are its advantages:the public credibility of the jury system makes the rate of appeal low,thus it excellently avoids all aspects of wasting resources; jury's public experience and collective deliberation can resist judges' bias from their profession and professional benefits; the social values brought in the jury trial can prevail over the lack of social experience,the chronic thinking and the difference of wits of the professional judges; the jury trial can remedy the defects of the professional judges' bureaucracy,rigidity and estrangement from the public. On the whole,the jury trial is still the effective way of people's participating in the judiciary.

     

/

返回文章
返回