江宏龙, 江万景. 人大个案监督评析——以合理性与合法性为视角[J]. 南昌航空大学学报(社会科学版), 2007, 9(2): 55-59.
引用本文: 江宏龙, 江万景. 人大个案监督评析——以合理性与合法性为视角[J]. 南昌航空大学学报(社会科学版), 2007, 9(2): 55-59.
JIANG Hong-long, JIANG Wan-jing. On the People’s Congress Case Supervision——taking the rationality and the validity as an angle of view[J]. JOURNAL OF NANCHANG HANGKONG UNIVERSITY(SOCLAL SCIENCES), 2007, 9(2): 55-59.
Citation: JIANG Hong-long, JIANG Wan-jing. On the People’s Congress Case Supervision——taking the rationality and the validity as an angle of view[J]. JOURNAL OF NANCHANG HANGKONG UNIVERSITY(SOCLAL SCIENCES), 2007, 9(2): 55-59.

人大个案监督评析——以合理性与合法性为视角

On the People’s Congress Case Supervision——taking the rationality and the validity as an angle of view

  • 摘要: 人大个案监督从其出现之初,便成为一个争议不休的话题.持肯定论者对实践领域中大量存在的司法腐败现象非常不满,认为克服这一弊端的良方便是由人大进行个案监督.然而,按照现代宪政理念,结合司法权本身固有的特征,审判权应当由法院独立行使.人大个案监督的出现,严重违背了审判权独立行使的原则,导致司法不公的加剧,打破了宪法所确立的政体平衡格局.

     

    Abstract: The people's congresses case supervision from the beginning became a controversial issue.Some people who are very dissatisfied with the presence of a large number of corruption in the judiciary think it is the best way to overcome this shortcoming.However,according to the modern constitutional concept,combining the characteristics inherent of judicial power,the court should exercise independently jurisdiction.The appearance of the people's congresses case supervision,have seriously violated the principle that the judicial authority exercises independently,caused judicial unfair intensifying,and broken the regime balanced pattern which the constitution has established.

     

/

返回文章
返回